MICHAEL L. WILLIAMS, APPELLANT
STATE OF ARKANSAS, APPELLEE
APPEAL FROM THE PULASKI COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT, FOURTH DIVISION. NO. CR-2012-3694. HONORABLE HERBERT T. WRIGHT, JUDGE.
Jeff Rosenzweig, for appellant.
Dustin McDaniel, Att'y Gen., by: Vada Berger, Ass't Att'y Gen., for appellee.
PHILLIP T. WHITEAKER, Judge. HIXSON and BROWN, JJ., agree.
PHILLIP T. WHITEAKER, Judge
Appellant Michael Williams appeals his Pulaski County jury convictions on five counts of aggravated robbery and five counts of theft of property, all with firearm enhancements, for which he was sentenced to a total of fifty years in the Arkansas Department of Correction. Williams contends tat the trial court erred in denying his motion for a directed verdict on all counts. Finding no error, we affirm.
The facts are as follows: on October 19, 2012, Courtney Griggs, Emily DeYmaz, Neal White, Andrew " Mack" Collins, and Brandon Bardell were robbed at gunpoint by several men at an apartment complex on Green Mountain Drive in Little Rock, Arkansas. None of the victims were certain how many men were involved in the robbery--the number ranged from three to five. One of the robbers held a gun to Griggs's head during the robbery. Griggs's purse, containing her keys, wallet, and mother's debit card, was stolen, as were DeYmaz's iPhone, keys, and identification. The robbers also stole wallets, keys, and cell phones from White, Collins, and Bardell. The robbers drove off in Collins's truck and a white Chevy Impala.
After the robbers left, Griggs called the police on the cell phone she had hidden in her boot. She also called her mother. At the time of the call to her mother, Griggs was hysterical. Griggs told her mother that someone with a scar on his face had held a gun to her head and that they had been robbed.
When the police arrived, they took statements from the victims. The victims were still quite upset and taking their information was difficult. While the victims were able to provide a general description of the robbers, none of the victims informed the officers that one of the robbers suffered from facial scarring.
Officers were able to use the Find My iPhone app on one of the stolen phones to track its location. Officers tracked the phone to a location in North Little Rock and observed a white Chevy Impala matching the suspect vehicle's description parked near the Cana Food Store on Pike Avenue. One of the officers observed Williams exit the store and open the door of the Impala. Williams was searched, and the officers located one of the stolen phones, Griggs's keys, the stolen debit card, and a firearm on his person. The tracked phone was located inside the store.
Williams was subsequently charged with five counts of aggravated robbery and five counts of theft of property, all with firearm enhancements. He was also charged with being a felon in possession of a firearm; however, that charge was severed for trial and later dismissed.
At trial, three of the victims (Griggs, DeYmaz, and White) positively identified Williams, who suffers from significant facial scarring, as the person who held a gun to Griggs's head during the robbery. Defense counsel did not object to the in-court identifications, but did question each witness extensively about their failure to mention Williams's scarring to the police on the night of the robbery or thereafter. Griggs admitted that her statement to police did not mention Williams's scarring, but testified of her phone call and identification of the facial scarring of her assailant to her mother on the night of the incident. This testimony was ...