B.T. v. State

          APPEAL FROM THE CRAIGHEAD COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT [NO. 16JJV-18-379] HONORABLE BARBARA HALSEY, JUDGE

          Terry Goodwin Jones, for appellant.

          Leslie Rutledge, Att'y Gen., by: Michael Zangari, Ass't Att'y Gen., for appellee.

          BART F. VIRDEN, JUDGE

         BT appeals the circuit court's determination of delinquency and challenges the sufficiency of the evidence that he committed residential burglary, theft of a firearm more than $2500, theft of property, and possession of a handgun. We affirm.

         I. Relevant Facts

         On October 15, 2018, the State filed a petition alleging that BT was a delinquent juvenile and asserted that on October 9, BT committed the following offenses: (1) residential burglary, Ark. Code Ann. § 5-39-201 (Repl. 2013); (2) theft of a firearm more than $2500, Ark Code Ann. § 5-36-103(b)(2)(C); (3) minor in possession of a handgun, Ark. Code Ann. § 5-73-119 (Repl. 2016); and (4) theft of property, Ark. Code Ann. § 5-36-103.

         At the hearing, captain Keith Carter and fire marshal Jason Wills of the Jonesboro Fire Department testified. Wills explained that he and Carter were investigating an arson that occurred on October 8, 2018, on Harrisburg Road in Jonesboro. Wills testified that on October 9, at around 1:45 p.m. while he and Carter investigating the arson, he saw BT and two other boys, GW and JS, walking south on Harrisburg Road. Wills and Captain Carter got in the fire department vehicle and drove toward the boys to speak to them, but boys had disappeared. Wills testified that they drove up and down Harrisburg Road and that Carter thought he saw someone standing on the back deck of a home immediately south of the home where the arson had occurred. Wills stated that around 2:35 p.m., the boys reappeared, and he observed JS and GW walking north on Harrisburg Road, and BT riding a hoverboard heading the same direction. Wills testified that JS was carrying a blue duffle bag, and GW was walking away from the other two. Wills recalled that when he and Carter first saw the boys, they "did not have anything on them." Wills testified that they caught up to BT in a nearby church parking lot and spoke to him about why he was not in school and asked him "general questions." While they were talking to BT, Wills and Carter noticed JS hiding behind a structure with the blue duffle bag open beside him. JS was instructed to put his hands on the wall, and Wills patted him down. Carter saw that the blue duffle bag was unzipped and that there were "multiple pistols" in it. Wills handcuffed JS, and by this time BT had walked away. Wills testified that he had not told BT he was not free to leave and that their conversation had been cut short because he had turned his attention to JS.

         Detective Joe Robinson with the Jonesboro Police Department testified that the fire marshals radioed in that they were looking for three juveniles possibly connected with an arson and a burglary they were investigating. The fire marshal reported that the juveniles possessed a duffle bag with two handguns, two or three tablets, a gaming system, ammunition, and other items. Robinson stated that he determined the property had come from Silas Orbison's house on Rosewood Circle and that the property line of Orbison's home and the house where the arson occurred are adjoining. The Orbisons reported that several long guns and a hoverboard had been taken, as well as property matching the description of the contents of the duffle bag. The long guns were found in the wooded area behind the Orbison's house underneath some sticks and leaves. Robinson testified that on October 10 or 11, he questioned BT at his home. BT denied knowing anything about the burglary or the arson, and he denied running away from the Orbison house on a hoverboard. Robinson explained that he did not search BT at the time he questioned him, though a probation search was later performed. Robinson explained that he watched the Harp's Food Store ("Harp's") surveillance video that shows all three boys walking together behind the store at 1:44 p.m.; BT riding a hoverboard in the parking lot at 2:30 and at 2:40 p.m.; and BT, JS, and GW walking together along Harrisburg Road toward the Orbison residence.

         Silas Orbison testified that around October 9, several items were taken from his home, including three iPads, two pistols, ammunition, five or six long guns, a hoverboard and charger, a shotgun, a camera, and various other things. Orbison stated that he had not given anyone permission to be inside his home that day and that while he was picking his children up from school, a neighbor called and told him that police were in the neighborhood near his home. Orbison returned to find that his home had been burgled. Orbison testified that the police returned most of the items except for the hoverboard and charger.

         BT recalled that on October 9, he skipped his last class of the day and went to McDonald's where he saw GW and JS. They decided to go look at the home that had burned. Afterward, BT testified, GW and JS went off together, and he walked over by the church. BT stated that neither JS nor GW possessed a duffle bag at that point. Five or ten minutes later, JS called BT and told him to meet back up with them in the church parking lot that was across the street from the burned home. GW had a hoverboard, which he let BT borrow, and JS was carrying a duffle bag. BT explained that around 2:30, as he was riding the hoverboard, Wills and Carter pulled up alongside him in their vehicle and asked him where he went to school, his name, and where he lived. When Wills finished questioning BT, BT proceeded toward Harp's where he saw GW, which was around 3:00 p.m. GW told him that JS had been arrested and that they had broken into a home together. BT testified that he returned the hoverboard to GW and walked home. BT stated that he had never been in the Orbison's house, that he did not act as a lookout or assist JS or GW in taking the items from the house, and that he never possessed a gun. Despite video surveillance confirming BT's presence in the vicinity at 1:44 p.m., BT disagreed with Wills's statement that he saw BT at 1:45 p.m., and he asserted that Wills could have seen him in the area at 2:10 p.m. but not before.

         Defense counsel moved to dismiss the charge of residential burglary, arguing that the State presented no evidence that BT had remained in a building unlawfully. On the theft-of-property charge, counsel asserted that the State presented no evidence that BT had taken the hoverboard or knew that it was stolen. Counsel contended that the State offered no proof that BT had ever had a handgun in his possession at any time. Defense counsel argued that there was no proof BT was ever in Orbison's home, that he removed any property from the home, or that he was responsible for the theft of the items from the home. The court denied the motions and found that BT's testimony lacked credibility.

         The circuit court found that BT had committed all four offenses, and he was adjudicated delinquent. The circuit court placed BT in the custody of the Division of Youth Services and recommended that BT undergo substance-abuse and mental-health treatment and receive educational services. BT timely filed a notice of appeal and disputes the sufficiency of the evidence supporting his adjudication of delinquency.

         II. Stand ...